JACKSONVILLE – Let’s get to it …

Where Jags Fans Aren't Pussies
JACKSONVILLE – Let’s get to it …
JACKSONVILLE – Let’s get to it …
John, I have been a Jags fan for almost 20 years since I moved to Jacksonville in 1998. I had season tickets in 2007. This season has been the most amazing since I have been a fan, probably because no one expected things to go this great. Win or lose Sunday, I have loved this season. But since the Jags have come this far, why not finish this amazing ride and beat the Pats then go win the Super Bowl? #DTWD
John: I thought a bit about your question and here’s what’s intriguing: I couldn’t come up with a great answer. First, I honestly haven’t given two seconds thought as to how the Jaguars would match up with either the Minnesota Vikings or Philadelphia Eagles. That’s not some don’t-look-too-far-ahead mandate from Head Coach Doug Marrone; rather, it’s because there are two weeks between the AFC Championship Game and the Super Bowl, so there is time for such thoughts should the Jaguars beat New England Sunday. But I have given thought as to whether the Jaguars can beat the Patriots and the thought here is they can. They shouldn’t be favored; the Patriots were the AFC’s top seed and playing at home for a reason. Quarterback Tom Brady is a Rushmore Player at his position, as is tight end Rob Gronkowski. But great players don’t make teams unbeatable and the Patriots absolutely aren’t unbeatable – and they are beatable by the Jaguars. Great defenses can beat great quarterbacks, and the Jaguars are capable of playing a great defensive game. Remember, too, the Jaguars were a reversed touchdown call against the Steelers from being ahead of the Patriots in the race for playoff positioning with two weeks remaining in the season; if the Steelers had beaten the Patriots in Week 15 rather than the other way around, the Jaguars would have been ahead of the Patriots at that moment. Does that mean the Jaguars are better? Not necessarily, but it does mean the three-game difference in the team’s final record might not be reflective of the strengths of the teams. The Patriots are a dynasty, and they’re difficult to beat in any situation. They’re particularly difficult to beat in Gillette Stadium in January. But it’s not impossible and the Jaguars have the defense to do it. They have had the offense at times, too. Why not finish the ride? I have a feeling they just might.
All I ask is to beat New England!!
John: Is that all?
The Jaguars have a very real shot at a trophy. This is one of the best defenses I have ever watched. If they can keep most of it intact, they will be in the playoffs a lot more in the future.
John: There’s time to worry about the future in the future. Focus for now on the Jaguars’ current shot at this trophy. The future is promised to no one – in the NFL, or anywhere else.
I saw a picture of Jalen Ramsey‘s locker with his uniform. There is a $20 taped to his lower-back pad. What is that all about?
John: He won’t say. Ramsey and video guru Max Hochman have a special relationship, so I assume Max knows, but no one else is privy to such information.
John: I get the love the Blake Bortles is getting right now and he deserves it. I’m just unsure how you can afford that salary cap hit of $19 million next year. I know this question/comment is not about #DTWD and you may think it’s a boring question, but I think one worthy of your thoughts on the options the Jags have BEYOND just taking the salary cap hit (rework the contract)?
John: It’s not boring, and I’ve shared thoughts quite often on this topic. It’s quite possible the sharing came on a day you weren’t reading, so my advice: read often – even if you have to move your lips while reading. As far as Bortles’ future, there is ample time for parsing through the details, but the overview is this: I think he’s going to be the quarterback here next season – and I think he has played well enough most of this season to justify that being the case. He can either play under the $19 million for which the final season of his rookie contract calls, or he and the Jaguars can negotiate a long-term deal. My guess is he will play at least part of the season under the $19 million because the Jaguars may not want to sign him to a long-term deal yet and because Bortles has little incentive to sign a shorter deal. The sides theoretically could renegotiate during or after the season – or the Jaguars could use the franchise tag on him for 2019. A lot of options work in the Jaguars’ favor in the short term. As far as having him play for $19 million next season, you can afford that because he’s a quarterback – and in the NFL, there are times and circumstances you must have room for a quarterback cap hit that high. This could be one of those times.
So, does Tom Coughlin come into the locker room this week and show off the two rings to remind the Jaguars that even when the Patriots are perfect … they aren’t? DUVAL!!
John: I don’t know that Coughlin will bring his rings for the occasion and don’t know that the occasion will occur in the locker room, but would be surprised if he doesn’t deliver that message this week. I imagine it will be delivered to players, and I imagine a lot of the principles behind the Giants’ two Super Bowl victories over New England will be in play for the Jaguars Sunday. The Giants beat the Patriots twice because they pressured quarterback Tom Brady, and because they believed they could win – and because they diligently carried out sound plans they believed would work. The details of the Jaguars approach this week will be built on the fundamentals of such a philosophy. Of that you can be almost sure.
You alluded to Jaguars safety Tashaun Gipson covering Gronk and another reader suggested linebacker Telvin Smith. Wouldn’t the most logical be Myles Jack? With his speed and size I think he would create the biggest problems for someone like Gronk.
John: He’s a possibility, but the Jaguars’ most common approach has been to use Smith and safety Barry Church on tight ends. My guess is much of the pregame talk about who covers Patriots tight end Rob Gronkowski will be for naught, because my guess is the Jaguars take the approach of playing base defense as well as possible and trusting that the techniques that allowed it to be the NFL’s No. 2 defense will continue to work. We’ll see.
O, I heard a report that the league takes over training schedules or something like that. Can you explain what this is and why it’s done?
John: The league is involved with conference title games because they’re the league’s conference title games, but the league doesn’t take over a team’s schedule. They assist in running press conferences, and you’ll see NFL Network broadcasting them, but the Jaguars’ schedule this week won’t change from last week.
Not exactly a question but more of an observation. To get out of Foxboro with a “W,” the Jaguars will have to beat the Patriots AND … the officials!! The calls against the Tennessee Titans were blatant and obvious. It’s sickening how biased the league and CBS is in favor of the Patriots!!!
John: You’re not the first fan to voice this concern and you won’t be the last. I heard the same concern from Jaguars fans before last week’s victory over the Steelers, and I didn’t sense any weirdness regarding the officiating. (Patriots fans, incidentally, would tell you the league is routinely against them and for everyone else. They hold this opinion because Patriots fans gonna fan just like everyone else).
Normally, this time of year is reserved for talking about the draft in April. How much fun are you and your colleagues having, this being the third straight week talking playoffs – and now, the AFC Championship Game?
Brad from Jacksonville, FL
I was 10 and sitting even with the north end zone goal post when Morten Andersen missed that kick for the Jaguars’ miracle run. The feeling in that stadium that day was when I fell in love with football. I have been an avid fan since then. On an odd day, Jacksonville allowed 42 points to Pittsburgh but still managed a win. You win how you win, but after all the years of being terrible, this feels like something special growing.
Revel in it. Chortle until your brains fall out. After all of the years of epoch losing you’ve had to endure, you deserve to celebrate, and I think you should take advantage of every second of celebration available to you this week before the next game. By the way, I was standing on the field just to the side of the left upright when Andersen missed.
Jim from Morrison, CO
Looks like Case Keenum is “The Man,” Vic. How does it feel to be wrong?
Really? Because he completed a desperation pass that won the game? If the defender had wrapped his arms around the receiver and held him inbounds, the clock would’ve expired. Prior to that pass, Keenum had thrown for no touchdowns, one interception and a 71 passer rating. He is not “The Man,” and the Vikings face the same dangerous decision on him the Jaguars are facing on Blake Bortles. Winning in the postseason could be costly for both franchises. The issue is: Will the Vikings pay Keenum as they would “The Man?” That’s a tough one because you’re talking about a longterm commitment. In my opinion, if the Vikings do that, they’ll open the door for the other three teams in the NFC North.
Bill from Sheboygan, WI
What are your thoughts on the Saints-Vikings game?
My first thought is how painful it has to be for Saints fans. How could a great athlete completely whiff on the tackle as the defender did? When it hurts this bad — Packers fans certainly know the feeling — I’m not sure football is worth the emotional investment. The poor people in New Orleans don’t deserve this heartache.
Simon from New York, NY
What are your favorite/least favorite personality traits in a person, football player, coach? Have those preferences changed since retirement?
Genuineness/insincerity, aggressiveness/softness, dignity/disloyalty. I’m more sure than ever before of what I like and don’t like in people. The bottom line is I like virtue, as defined by the roles in which we’re cast.
David from San Francisco, CA
We’ve seen the Jaguars improve with the free-agent signings of Calais Campbell, A.J. Bouye and Barry Church. As they continue their search to pay “The Man,” how can this team remain competitive in future seasons and maintain financial stability?
The quarterback position will define the Jaguars’ future. I don’t think Blake Bortles is the future. The Jaguars are the result of a unique situation. That team isn’t just about high picks and free-agent signings, it’s about the uncapped year in 2010 and stripping the team for sale, which left the Jaguars so horribly beneath the cap floor the league had to give them an exemption from the cap minimum and allow them to recover in stages. I thought it was unfair and the Jaguars should’ve lost draft picks for noncompliance, but nobody complained because the Jaguars were horribly uncompetitive and irrelevant. As a result, the Jaguars were able to take an ultra-aggressive posture in free agency. They were so flush with cap room they didn’t have to worry about their free-agent misses, and they had plenty of them. They still have room to spend. It’s almost as though they were reborn as an expansion franchise. They are not a realistic model.
Jerry from Savannah, GA
“We must kick the extra point to finalize the game.” Succinct and to the point. Steratore is a classic.
I love him. “There’s no flag on the play.” He didn’t explain why there was no flag or for what there was no flag, there’s just no flag. Deal with it.
Jonathan from Saint Joseph (folks, please include the state)
Has Tony Romo turned into a typical fan? In the Titans/Pats game he said the Titans need to run the ball to surprise the Pats on a third-and-three. Then, when they throw it to convert a first down, he says “no one knows the Titans run the ball more on third-and-short except Bellichick, and he stacked the box.”
He talks too much and he was at his worst on Saturday. I watched Saturday’s games with friends, which is kind of a first for me. I prefer to watch in silence and study the game as it unfolds. I guess I was being new, and I liked it. It helped me ignore “Chatty Cathy.” Be that as it may, I couldn’t help but hear him exclaim pleadingly following one Titans play, “What are they doing?” He’s a fan! He talks incessantly, even as the play is unfolding: “That motion caused the linebacker to move with the man in motion, which means it’s man coverage, yada, yada,” or “they’re unbalanced to the left so he needs to change the play to run to the right.” It’s just too much. He’s missing the drama in his obsession for being the great scheme explainer. The Titans were slowly but surely being outclassed by the Patriots. Say that! That was the story.
Jake from Knoxville, TN
What did you think of Foles?
He did what the Eagles needed him to do, and that’ll work as long as the Eagles don’t need him to do more. The day they need him to be a star, it’s over. That’s when you need “The Man.”
Edward from Canton, SD
Are you more happy for the Jags or sad for the Steelers
Happy for the Jags. The Steelers didn’t need to lose to the Patriots one more time. It was over for the Steelers the night they lost Ryan Shazier. Cris Collinsworth more or less explained that the following week in his analysis of why the Ravens were running roughshod on the Steelers defense. It’s another example of why I think Collinsworth is the best. Inside linebacker is a critical position in the Steelers’ 3-4 defense. Shazier is a star. James Farrior and Levon Kirkland were stars. The Steelers lost Lawrence Timmons in free agency, then Shazier to injury and his replacement to injury almost immediately. That defense was toast. I’m happy for the Jaguars and I was happy to see Shazier in good spirits on Sunday. The best feeling I’ll get from this season will be from seeing that man walk again.
Tim from Durham, NC
The announcers spent the last few minutes criticizing the Steelers’ decision-making and didn’t feel like mentioning teams that give up 45 points don’t usually win games. Where does the Pittsburgh defense go from here?
Baltimore ran the ball at will against the Steelers, and the Browns moved up and down the field on a defense that was resting only Cameron Heyward. The Steelers have to replace Shazier. It begins with that.
Oscar from Milwaukee, WI
Vic, congrats to the Jaguars on making the AFC title game, however, I am not completely sold on the Jags’ defense. I saw a lot of missed tackles and a lot of unguarded receivers. Despite that, the defense is still highly ranked. How do I reconcile this discrepancy between rankings and my eye test?
The Steelers offense is exceptional. Ben Roethlisberger was indefatigable. He threw for 469 yards and five touchdowns, and that doesn’t include an open-field lateral pass to Le’Veon Bell for a touchdown. Antonio Brown is better on one good leg than most receivers are on two. Bell is the king of multi-tasking. I think James Conner was a big loss. I think he was developing into their short-yardage pounder. The Jags defense kind of ate the pizza after the touchdown return. It really fell in love with itself, and it better fall out of love real fast because just ahead is the greatest quarterback of all time, Tom Brady.
Greg from Danbury, CT
Bortles performed very well. Well enough to take down Brady and Co.?
Bortles can’t beat Brady. Fournette has to do it. Everything Bortles did against the Steelers was the result of the Steelers’ fear of Fournette. I routinely saw eight guys in the box with a ninth guy inching up. Bortles could throw short over the middle because the inside linebackers didn’t dare leave the line of scrimmage. For the Jaguars to win in New England, they must run the ball and rush the passer. Bill Belichick knows what he must prevent. So did Mike Tomlin, but he couldn’t do it.
Tim from Sun Prairie, WI
Vic, any word on the expected strength of the 2018 draft class yet?
It’s getting stronger with each underclassman declaring eligibility. There were several last week. College football is suffering from these defections. I remember when Woody Hayes said a team loses one game for every sophomore in its starting lineup. Back then, freshmen weren’t elgible. That changed in 1973 and now players are going pro after just two seasons in college football. Larry Fitzgerald and LeSean McCoy never got to their junior years, and they weren’t redshirts. The ACC proposed interesting new redshirt rules last week, and I’m in favor of them. I’m in favor of anything that’ll help college football retain its talent. Maybe college football needs to go back to freshmen being ineligible.
Clint from Boom Bay, WI
I was feeling we needed to bring in some AFC North blood to the defensive coordinator position, and I’m very excited about Pettine. Do you think he can bring the same edge to our defense Zimmer has to Minnesota?
It’s a good thought. The Packers need some AFC North blood. They need that kind of nastiness. Mike Zimmer has brought the AFC North to the NFC North and that style of play is going to intensify. Mike Pettine will be looking for AFC North-type players in the draft.
David from Madison, WI
What do you think of the Big 10 scheduling games on Fridays?
It indicates to me a decline in high school football popularity within the conference’s footprint, which saddens me.
Sean from Arlington Heights, IL
I have a lot of respect for what Mike Tomlin has accomplished as a coach, but kicking the onside kick with two timeouts and the two-minute warning left was a bad decision. Not using the timeouts before the two-minute warning was inexcusable.
He tried the onside kick because he had no confidence in his defense. He knew his defense couldn’t stop the Jaguars. The Jaguars offensive line is bigger and stronger than the Steelers’ defensive front, and Fournette is the new Earl Campbell. The only chance the Steelers had of winning the game was sending it into overtime, winning the coin toss and scoring a touchdown on their first possession. Do you remember what I wrote about the previous meeting between the two teams? Forget about the five interceptions and the long run at garbage time. It was the Jaguars’ ability to run the ball off their own goal line and move the ball out to midfield at crunch time that resonated with me. That’s the kind of physical dominance we saw again yesterday.
Andrew from Minneapolis, MN
Any plan to set up some merchandise for sale to pay the bandwidth bills? “Ask Vic” T-Shirts, hats and things?
I have no plans to monetize this site. My sole purpose for creating this site is to have a place to write the truth as I perceive it to be. If you don’t like it, don’t read it, but those who like it and read it will never have to pay for it.
Adam from Wausau, WI
I know you don’t know what Twitter and Facebook are, but I know you’re a big free speech guy. What are your thoughts on the recent revelation Twitter (a private company that lets you say whatever is on your mind whenever you want) is limiting certain kinds of speech they don’t agree with? Just for the record, I love when you interject politics into your forum.
It’s Twitter’s site and it has the right to express itself as it wishes. If you don’t like it, start your own site. What I’m against is any change in the first law of the mass media, that public figures are subject to public scrutiny. I recently listened to a lecture from a learned person on the Civil War media. I was most intrigued to know Sherman wanted to execute a New York Herald reporter for writing something Sherman didn’t want written. The reporter’s life was saved by his publisher, Horace Greeley, following a negotiation in which Sherman agreed not to execute the reporter provided reporters would henceforth include their names in their accounts. I guess that’s how the byline was born. Imagine a nation that would execute a man for telling the truth. We truly are blessed by our freedom of speech laws, and they must never be compromised.
Blaine from Bagley, WI
Two games remain. Who are your picks for the Super Bowl?
New England and Philadelphia. Brady is nearly unbeatable, and the homefield will give the Eagles an advantage, especially in the cold against a dome team.
Robert from Rotterdam, The Netherlands
Vic, it was just like you said; the Jaguars ran the ball and rushed the passer. Seems retirement has made you sharper than ever.
It was obvious. Fans ignore the obvious because they like to tickle themselves.
Tim from Lancaster, PA
Can Brady hit the same throws as Roethlisberger at this age?
Absolutely! He’s not as mobile in the pocket as he was, but his arm is still strong and accurate. He and Roethlisberger throw the deep ball as well as any quarterbacks I’ve ever seen.
Jon from Bloomfield, NJ
They called Telvin Smith for taunting after the play. It was clearly during the play and, to me, that’s an important distinction.
I completely agree.
JACKSONVILLE – Let’s get to it …
JACKSONVILLE – A lot of happiness. A lot of joy. A lot of #Duvals. A lot of #DTWDs.
And why not?
The Jaguars are in the AFC Championship Game. I’m not making this up.
Let’s get to it …
JACKSONVILLE – Let’s get to it …
I tried to make this gif back in week 5 but I couldn’t get it right and it was taking too much time so I gave up on it.
But, it seems appropriate now so fuck it, here’s what I was trying to do:
JACKSONVILLE – Let’s get to it …
62-7, John! 62-7 was the final score in Dan Marino’s final game when the Dolphins played the Jaguars (real fans know). Let’s hope for a similar outcome Sunday. This will be Big Ben’s final game. If we can force retirement, then they should just induct the whole defense in the Jags Ring of Honor.
John: You’re excited, Justin. That much is clear. And it’s understandable. These are exciting times around the Jaguars, and the NFL playoffs are heart-starting and heart-stopping stuff. But this is a different circumstance than Jaguars-Dolphins following the 1999 season. The Jaguars had home-field advantage with the NFL’s best record that season while the Dolphins had limped to Jacksonville on a short week as a wild card. Marino was clearly very close to retirement and past his prime. Ben Roethlisberger and the Steelers are a controversial call from the NFL’s best record this season with home-field advantage throughout the playoffs – and the Steelers have won 10 of 11 entering the postseason. Roethlisberger also has played at a high level pretty much since a Week 5 loss to the Jaguars, so don’t get the idea he’s limping anywhere right now – or that he’s close to retirement. The Jaguars clearly are capable of winning Sunday, but I wouldn’t go this game in expecting them to turn in another one-sided victory. A victory of any margin would be as significant a victory as this franchise has registered. Ever.
Idk, Jack seems more interested in hitting people than playing football. #FightOn #TeamLee #LewisandMJDarecoolthough
John: What?
Lot of hate out there, both locally and nationally, for a team that had just three wins last year, yet is one of eight teams left in the divisional round of the NFL playoffs. Not sure where the disconnect is other than haters gonna hate I guess. Even if the season were to end at Pittsburgh on Sunday, we’ve got a lot to hang our hat on this year compared to seasons past. Keep expectations high, but let’s not forget the fact we’re still playing in mid-January.
John: The time for savoring what the Jaguars accomplished will come, and that should be a satisfying experience for fans because this team has accomplished a lot. For now, it’s playoff time. That means fans gonna fan and media gonna media, so sit back and enjoy it all as it happens.
If the Jags win 10-3 this weekend I will not complain one bit. I don’t care what Bortles’ stats are!
John: You are not alone.
Why do we not see more designed plays for Blake Bortles to use his mobility more? Once he started moving and running, he looked like a different quarterback versus Buffalo. I feel the team is trying to make him a pocket passer first, which he is not. Let him roll out more, let him run more. It seems get him to relax and start throwing a better football.
John: The reason the Jaguars don’t usually do this is a belief that Bortles indeed is perfectly capable of being effective in the pocket, as well as a belief that he developed as a pocket passer this season. Evidence throughout much of the season – until the regular-season finale and the Wild Card game, really – supports this. But the Jaguars are now in the middle of what is very much a one-and-done, all-chips-to-middle tournament. If there are situations that call for Bortles to run – and for the Jaguars to design plays for him to run – I’m all for it. And I would guess the Jaguars do that at least a few times on Sunday.
Mr. O, does it feel like everything that’s happening around this game is turning us into the bad guys? Like Ben saying he’s coming for us, AB coming back, and now I see Ryan Shazier is back in the building. Obviously he’s not practicing but still him being there has got to be like a “we’re-winning-this-for-him” type of thing. I don’t want to rain on the parade but I see storm clouds brewing…
John: So?
What do they mean when they say, “It really helps a quarterback to be in the same system and really understand it”? I’ve heard a lotta stuff about Blake having three or four different offensive coordinators and having to learn a new offense (system) every year. But they also say that Tom Brady has a great understanding of his system, and the Patriots have had a lot of different offensive coordinators since Brady has been in New England. So what’s the difference in the way they talk about it?
John: It indeed can hinder a young quarterback to have to learn a new system every year with new terminology, new philosophy, etc. Bortles essentially has had a different coordinator three of his four seasons, with each of those coordinators – Jedd Fisch, Greg Olson and Nathaniel Hackett – having different terminology and pretty different approaches as far as how they wanted the offense run and the quarterback position played. While Brady indeed has had different offensive coordinators, those coordinators have run basically the same offensive system with Charlie Weis first running the offense from 2000-2004 then Josh McDaniels – who worked for the Patriots while Weis was the coordinator – assuming the role two years after Weis left and holding it for all but three seasons since. Brady has changed coordinators a few times, but he always essentially has run the same system. That hasn’t been nearly as much the case for Bortles.
No one says we can win. Last victory was a fluke. We don’t have the offense to keep up. They will run on our defense. There is no way their quarterback throws picks again. We have no chance. We are playing with house money. Boy! I cannot think of a better mantra to tell the Jags players all week. I LOVE IT! Please pick against us, please say we have no chance. Seems to me to be the perfect thing to tell these players to get them fired up and in the mindset to do just that! #DTWD!
John: #DTWD
Do you think the Steelers are playing Antonio Brown just so Jalen Ramsey will shadow him? Meaning Brown isn’t at full health, but playing just to take out the best corner in the league?
John: I don’t cover the Steelers so I don’t pretend to have a feel for the pulse of their inner workings on the level I do the Jaguars. The word from Pittsburgh this week is that Brown is healthy. If that’s the case, then you play him because he’s that good. If he’s not fully healthy, it seems that would benefit the Jaguars because it would mean the NFL’s best receiver isn’t at full strength.
Why can I not focus at work, my appetite is off and I don’t even feel like drinking in anticipation of Sunday?
John: Because playoffs.
Sunday at one point they zoomed in on Dante Fowler Jr. and it was a revelation. I had completely forgotten about Fowler. Is it because he hasn’t had any of the dumb penalties or that he just isn’t making huge plays? How has his play been? Here is to hoping his name gets brought up a lot on Sunday due to sacking little Ben!
John: Fowler is playing well. He’s not yet an elite pass rusher and he may not reach that level, but he plays with an energy, effort and a violence that makes him important as a third-down/nickel player. On a defense that swarms and plays with violence and energy and effort he’s a key component.
Do you expect T.J. Yeldon to be active this week due to him being better in pass protection since the Steelers were No. 1 in sacks this season?
John: Yes.
Should the Jaguars stack the box against the Steelers, playing man to man, forcing Ben to beat us?
John: The Jaguars should play their scheme, which is to emphasize taking away the run on early downs then to rush the quarterback with four players and play with seven in coverage behind those four. That approach has made the Jaguars very difficult to beat defensively this season – and it worked in Pittsburgh in October.
Hey John, is there anything about the 3-4 and Pittsburgh’s personnel in particular that could create a good matchup for the Jags as it relates to the running game? Or will our success running the ball be a fingers-crossed situation?
John: /crosses fingers
When are you going to stop blowing smoke and hiding behind not-so-funny jokes? All of the “experts” (and I use Phil Simms, Boomer Esiason and Steve Young as examples) contend that BB5 is not and will not be a viable starting QB in the NFL. What makes their evaluations mute? Certainly not because John says so.
JACKSONVILLE – Let’s get to it …
John, conceptually how do you think the Steelers will make adjustments this week? I didn’t play football, so I do not know how teams prepare from week to week. Is there anything different they will do this week since this is the playoffs and not the regular season?
John: I don’t think the Steelers will change their game plan because it’s the playoffs, but I do expect them to adjust based on what happened in the Jaguars’ Week 5 victory – and based on how they are playing now compared to earlier in the season. I expect the Steelers to look at Week 5 and see that they probably got away from running Le’Veon Bell too early, and I expect them to say, “We need to run Le’Veon Bell more throughout the game, more than we did in Week 5.” This is an intriguing issue in this game because Bell was running well in the first half in October and wasn’t used much in the second half as the Jaguars took control. Can he match his early Week 5 effectiveness? Will the Jaguars’ addition of defensive tackle Marcell Dareus in October help against Bell? I also expect the Steelers to load the box against Jaguars running back Leonard Fournette and not let him pinball off tacklers as he was able to do on a couple of occasions in October. There will be other adjustments for both teams, but these are two to watch.
John, Blake Bortles sure takes a lot of verbal jabs from his fellow NFL players. I don’t think I have ever seen anything quite like it. From what I can tell Blake lets it roll off his back but it has to wear on a guy after a while. Do you think this constant criticism has a negative impact on his play from what you have seen?
John: No.
Zone, my anniversary is Sunday, and the wife is giving me grief for caring more about game-day party plans than “our” day. Permission to tell her she can—?
John: No permission needed. Fight the good fight. Tell her the heart wants what the heart wants. Stay true to the cause. And be prepared for it all to go horribly and inevitably oh-so wrong.
So, one of my friends asked me to make a road trip with him this Sunday. I told him you know how I feel about the Jaguars and I never miss a game and no way will I miss this one. Am I bad friend?
John: You can tell your friend he can—
O-Man, I never wish ill on a player and I certainly don’t celebrate when the inevitable injury occurs. Having said that, how big do you think the absence of Steelers linebacker Ryan Shazier will be this weekend? He is a freak athlete and the heart and soul of their defense. Without him, I think we can control the ground game.
John: Shazier arguably was the Steelers’ best defensive player. They have played well without him, but they’re not as good without his freakish speed and athleticism. I don’t think his absence will allow the Jaguars to control the ground game because the Jaguars have shown little evidence of controlling the ground game whoever the opponent. But it sure could open up a play or two in the middle of the field in the passing game and open up the opportunity for a big play or two in the running game.
The weather for Sunday looks to be a bit chilly. How much of a factor do you think this will be?
John: Big.
May I remind you someone was 9 of 14 for less than 100 yards in Week 5 of this season? It’s a proven formula that must be repeated. We need the offensive line to dominate here to put up the rushing numbers from Week 5.
John: The Jaguars rushed for the most part OK in that game, and they had an unbelievable series when they ran on 12 consecutive plays to drain clock and kick an important field goal. Fournette also rushed for 91 yards on 27 carries before his 90-yard fourth-quarter run put him at 181 yards for the game and significantly increased his average. My point? The Jaguars’ offensive line probably isn’t going to dominate the Steelers or any other team enough to single-handedly carry the offense. The Jaguars need balance, and they’re going to need Bortles and the receivers to make plays in the passing game to get it.
Mr. Zone: You’ve written that you expect BB5 to be under center next year. I tend to agree and that makes me a sad Jaguars fan. You’ve pointed out (correctly) that BB5 has been responsible for winning games this year. But doggone, the last few weeks have been rough to watch. I’m not asking for Aaron Rodgers, Big Ben or Drew Brees to sling it 45 times a game but even completing half of the passes might get teams from stacking the box and selling out against the run. For instance, Minnesota has three quality quarterbacks on the roster but none signed past this year. I know it’s hard if you’re dropping 19 large on BB5 next year, but do you bring in anyone else to compete?
John: I don’t know what the Jaguars will do at quarterback next offseason, but I suppose I look at it at least somewhat like this: Executive Vice President of Football Operations Tom Coughlin, General Manager Dave Caldwell and Head Coach Doug Marrone presumably did a good job putting this team together this past offseason. I presume that because they’re one of eight teams still playing football this weekend. Those men probably made good decisions at least part of the time when judging this roster and determining whether to make changes at certain positions. If those men – who presumably did a decent job putting together the roster – decide that Blake Bortles is a better option than available rookies or veterans when weighing other factors such as needs at other positions, cost, etc., are you absolutely sure that should make you sad? If the Jaguars believe there is a better option available than Bortles, they’ll bring him in. Fans may or may not agree with the decision they make, but don’t doubt that they will try to improve the quarterback position – or any position – if it’s possible and feasible to do so.
I don’t get why we are waving white towels at football games when our primary color, I thought, was teal. And by the way, I would like to see more teal in our uniforms and clothing. Let’s make more of a statement with TEAL terrible towels!!!!! Let’s Go Jagggggssssssss!!!
John: What a glorious time it is in Jaguars Nation when the big crisis is the color of towel being waved at a sold-out home playoff game. #Divisionchampionproblems
After watching the “Playoff Memories” video, I can’t help but think this game could have a very similar ending. It wouldn’t surprise me if it came down to one final drive in the fourth quarter, and it wouldn’t surprise me if Blake Bortles gets it done with his legs on that drive. It also wouldn’t surprise me if it results in the Jaguars coming back to Jacksonville with a win and momentum heading into a matchup against Tom Brady and the Patriots. This time, though, it will be for a chance to go to the Super Bowl, and the Jaguars will go to Gillette Stadium with the best defense in the NFL. #DTWD
John: #DTWD
John, I love Jalen Ramsey as much as the next Jags fan, but can we hold off on prematurely crowning him the best Jags cornerback? Pretty sure Rashean Mathis still deserves that title, and going into this game against the Steelers I can’t help but think of all the times Mathis was a thorn in the Steelers side.
John: I didn’t cover the Jaguars from 2001-2010, so I missed much of Mathis’ time with the Jaguars. I therefore can’t say whether or not there were seasons in which Mathis was better than Ramsey. I can say that I’ve covered 23 NFL seasons, and Ramsey is the best cornerback I’ve covered during that time with A.J. Bouye a close second.
The Steelers have a winning record at home against every NFL team since drafting Ben Roethlisberger in 2004 except New England (2-5) and your very own Jacksonville Jaguars (1-4). They know it and we know it. Can you speak to the relevancy of this?
JACKSONVILLE – Let’s get to it …
This feels like going against the Broncos again in the playoffs. Everybody is killing us right now. Of course none of our favorite national media will pick us, but if we play our game we can beat anyone. Hope Good Bortles shows up this game.
John: Let Divisional Playoff Week officially begin – and indeed, no NFL playoff week is complete without complaints about a lack of respect, love or recognition. I say this not to dismiss the idea that the Jaguars this week will be overlooked by many and loved by few; that almost certainly will be the case. Few national analysts will pick the Jaguars. Few fans nationwide will give them a chance. People in Pittsburgh? The Pittstonians? The ‘Burghers? They certainly will dismiss the little Jaggies’ chances against Big Ben and his Mighty Band of Steel Marauders. All of that’s OK, and here’s why: National analysts – analysts of any kind, actually – don’t decide NFL games. Whatever the perception, the Jaguars indeed can beat anyone left in the postseason. That includes the Steelers. I believe the Jaguars have fewer ways to win than the Steelers, meaning the Jaguars probably need to play with a lead, get turnovers and make a big play or two – and I don’t believe the Jaguars can afford to get down multiple scores. But can they win in Pittsburgh? Absolutely because they already … you know … did.
Hi O! What is the goal in the playoffs? From what I have read/heard from fans and national reporters, it seems that you need to score 25 points or more, even if you lose.
John: Hold on. I have to Google this.
Is it fair to wonder if Keelan Cole should be on the field more than Hurns? I love Allen Hurns, and that crawl off the field to save a 10-second runoff against the Chargers was the personification of GRIT, but Keelan was ballin’ and Hurns wasn’t all that productive prior to the injury.
John: Cole played 32 snaps on Sunday against the Bills; Hurns played 31. Here’s the reality about the Jaguars’ wide receivers right now: there is no easy answer. No receiver in the group represents a magical solution to the passing game issues because there’s not a go-to, elite player in the bunch. The Jaguars have one of those: Allen Robinson, and he’s on season-ending injured reserve with a torn anterior cruciate ligament. What the Jaguars have at receiver is three young players – rookies Dede Westbrook and Cole and first-year veteran Jaydon Mickens – who play with the inconsistency that the combination of talent and inexperience often produces. They also have a couple of veterans – Hurns and Marqise Lee – who have been limited by injuries and are not yet back to their pre-injury level. The bad news for the Jaguars is Robinson isn’t returning until next season. The good news: at various times in their careers and this season the five aforementioned players have played at a high level. They can make plays. They are capable. The challenge now: have one or a couple of them make plays Sunday in the biggest game of their lives.
Hey, O: A 2:00 a.m. wake up to watch the game over here is hard work, but the “W” makes it worthwhile. Any advice for telling the wife it’s happening again this week?
John: Yes, tell your wife I said she can—
John: It’s not you. It’s him. And he is.
If a forward shovel pass hits the ground, is it ruled as an incomplete pass or a fumble? What if the quarterback is in the process of getting sacked?
John: It’s an incomplete pass.
Big O, I know there were multiple factors affecting Blake’s performance on Sunday. Among the most significant and potentially most concerning was that he seemed extremely nervous. He seemed to have been very cognizant of the fact that if he turned the ball over the game would be at risk. Was this first-playoff jitters? Was it that the coaches beat the game plan into him so much that he psyched himself out? Something else? More importantly, can he shed it before the weekend? Can he regain his confidence now that the first game is notched in his belt?
John: You asked a bunch of questions and only time will determine answers. Yes, Bortles seemed nervous Sunday – and I have no doubt he was aware that not turning the ball over was the No. 1 key to victory. I think the Jaguars will have a game plan Sunday that allows him to throw earlier and therefore play looser. It’s not uncommon for quarterbacks to struggle in their first postseason games. Will a game’s worth of experience and a more aggressive plan mean improvement for Bortles? We’ll see.
John, I can be just as disappointed with Blake as anyone else, but I find myself rooting for the guy. There is a lot to like; I think he’s improving over time.
John: #DTWD
Blake gets a lot of attention on his shortcomings, but watching Leonard Fournette … he appears to be giving up too soon on his runs. He had an open-field run with one defender to beat and he goes down with his shoulder instead of moving around him. He would have scored a 55-yard touchdown if he beat him. Blake is not getting the run game needed to win. What is up with our running back?
John: The Jaguars’ run-game struggles in recent weeks have been well-documented. The line has had trouble run-blocking, especially on the interior. The Jaguars also have faced a lot of run-oriented fronts. Fournette has been injured. But Fournette’s elusiveness as you note hasn’t been ideal, especially late in the season. The thought here is the ankle and lower-body issues of late probably play a role in that. We probably won’t know until next season.
John, I think at this time of year a team needs to game plan recognizing exactly who they are, not who they want to be. On offense, I think that means taking advantage of Blake’s mobility and not expecting a dominating running game. They should try to get Blake going in the passing game with more intermediate and deep passes on early downs. What do you think?
John: I think the Jaguars will need to be more aggressive and take at least a few shots downfield Sunday. They certainly will have to do it more against the Steelers than they did against the Bills. I believe they will do that. Stay tuned.
How can you not be majorly concerned about the lack of development in Blake? Something is horribly wrong when the offensive game plan is built around having to defend against your supposed franchise quarterback making-game altering mistakes. Dave Caldwell made a career-altering mistake by drafting him. It is a shame that the coaching staff has to keep trying to minimize his detriment to the team.
John: There’s this …
Blake Bortles threw a touchdown on fourth-and-goal in the playoffs in the second half of a tied game. That’s big-time stuff, John.
John: … and then there’s this.
I’ve heard a lot recently that we were sixth-ranked offense this year. I’d like to ask if defensive touchdowns count toward that statistic? If so, it would seem our offense may not deserve such a high ranking – and even if not, our defense has a lot to do with putting them in good positions to score.
John: The Jaguars were sixth in the NFL in total yards and fifth in total points. That statistic doesn’t at all prove that the Jaguars were consistent offensively, because that wasn’t the case. But it does show that the team not only was capable of scoring in bunches at times but that the offense was capable of producing points and yards on its own at times.
There are a lot of good stats from Sunday, but here’s my favorite: zero injuries! The key disadvantage to not getting the bye was avoided and the Jaguars will be the healthiest they’ve been in a while going to Pittsburgh. Go Jags!
JACKSONVILLE – Let’s get to it …
Tim from Sun Prairie, WI
Vic, the Packers can’t pay all their WRs. Do they part with Nelson or Cobb? Is Montgomery a slot WR after all?
You’re not thinking new. You’re perseverating over what’s old. The Packers need to get younger and faster at wide receiver. The concern should be for adding players, not retaining them. I’m not being disrespectful. That’s just the way it is in the NFL. It’s a game of replacement.
Robert from Rotterdam, The Netherlands
Vic, I don’t like reaching for accolades but if Jacksonville’s defense carries the team to a Super Bowl in the same fashion it carried them to a win yesterday, should they be considered among the all-time great defenses?
Why wait? Overreaction is all around us. I am officially proclaiming “Sacksonville” to be the greatest defense in the history of the world.
Ben from Hilo, HI
What surprised you most during the wild-card weekend?
I guess I was most surprised by the Chiefs’ collapse, but I don’t know why. Andy Reid’s Chiefs teams bear a strong resemblance to his Eagles teams, soft.
Leif from Saint Croix Falls, WI
Vic, what are your thoughts on Ben Roethlisberger and his odds of retiring after the season ends?
During the first half of the Indianapolis game, he looked old and I felt strongly I was seeing him playing in his final season. Then, in the fourth quarter, he caught fire. He moved his offense up and down the field, rallied for the win and, in the process, looked young again, and it’s been that way ever since. I’m not sure about his future now. After a 14-season career in which the quarterback protections often weren’t applied to him, I could certainly understand why he would consider retirement, but I’m not seeing anything in his game that suggests eroding skills. Be that as it may, the Steelers need to draft a quarterback high.
Darren from Chicago, IL
You’ve stated several times before that Mike McCarthy is a leader of men. Considering all the coaching changes at (the Packers) and around the league, how high on your priority list is that trait and how hard is it to find it among candidates? And thanks for continuing your work!
It’s never been more important and we’re seeing evidence of that right now as it pertains to the Packers. When I first suggested the Packers need to become new, there was outrage in my inbox. What do you mean, they stormed? Aaron Rodgers will recover. He’ll be back and everything will be fine again, they said. Darren, I’ve lived a football life, and it was easy for me to see what was going to happen with the Packers, and the best news for Packers fans is they have a coach who also sees it and isn’t afraid to do what needs to be done. Change is everywhere. It’s in coaching and personnel, and it’ll extend to the roster, where I think change is most important. Coach McCarthy is a leader of men. He knows what needs to be done and he won’t rest until it’s accomplished. A new GM is in place. I believe Brian Gutkekunst is the right man for the job, and it’s believed he shares Coach McCarthy’s vision for what needs to happen for the Packers to begin a new run. Soon, we’ll begin getting a feel for what that vision is.
Randy from Medicine Hat, AB
Towards the end of the first quarter in the Jaguars/Bills game … Tony Romo said “we are in for a good, old-fashioned field position game.” Amazingly, that was what I was thinking at that very moment.
Romo says many things. He’s the “Chatty Cathy” of TV football analysts. After the Bills failed to draw the Jaguars offsides and called a time out before the play clock expired, Romo said the Bills should’ve taken the delay of game penalty and saved the timeout, since five yards would’ve been meaningless in the field goal attempt. Then, before the ball could be snapped for the field goal attempt, the Jaguars jumped offsides, giving the Bills first and goal. I guess that’s why you call timeout, Romo should’ve said, but he never did.
Michael from Fernandina Beach, FL
What do you think the Jags’ chances are next week at Pittsburgh?
In all sincerity, the Jaguars have a defense that can beat anybody. I don’t think “Sacksonville” deserves to be mentioned, yet, with the great defenses of all time, but it’s good, real good.
Jesse from Bethlehem, PA
Can you tell us anything about Brian Gutekunst? Should Packers fans be excited about this?
I love him. He’s a great scout and a wonderfully personable football man. He’s dynamite in press conferences and he’ll help bridge gaps between football and the other departments within the Packers. He’s just what the Packers need.
Bryan from Springfield, WI
Is picking the picker a crystal ball business?
It absolutely is because you never know how a picker will pick until he’s on the clock.
Roger from Auburn, CA
Vic, if the Packers GM position is such an attractive position, why would the Packers promote an internal candidate when the past several drafts have left us with a mediocre talent base?
I can’t get it across, can I? Roger, in my opinion, the Packers’ extended run at the bottom of the draft order weakened the team’s roster. Gutekunst won’t have that problem this year, and it might not be a problem for a few years.
Adam from Wausau, WI
I saw the NFL ratings were down almost 10 percent. How will this affect the cap going forward?
Ratings don’t affect the salary cap unless they result in a less lucrative TV contract. The cap is determined by revenue.
Chris from Bozeman, MT
I’m curious what you think it means when someone says “the Packers’ way”? You really only hear this in reference to teams like GB, NE and Pitt. To me, it’s a little smug. All teams place value on an opera non verba philosophy.
A little smug? For those of you who weren’t required to take Latin, “opera non verba” means “actions, not words.” The only reason I know the meaning is because Tom Coughlin hung a sign in the hallway with those words on it. He was real proud of it, in an altar boy sort of way, and he asked me, “How do you like the sign?” I told him I didn’t know what it meant. “I thought you went to Catholic school,” he said. “It was an elementary school, not a seminary,” I said. I don’t think the sign was a big hit with the players. As for the Packers’ way, the Patriots’ way, the Steelers’ way, it’s a smug way of saying draft Rodgers, draft Brady, draft Roethlisberger. Players, not ways.
Bob from Green Bay, WI
If the President proposed eliminating professional sports to combat global warming, I’ll bet you would have a different take on the subject.
Reducing carbon dioxide in the atmosphere offends you? I think we need to have an open mind on this issue, because a lot of people live on the water’s edge and if they have to move in mass, everybody is going to suffer. I’m being asked to avoid political discussions. This has nothing to do with politics. Those who think it does are the problem.
Mark from Nashville, TN
What are some of your all-time favorite responses from news conferences?
When Chuck Noll would get questioned about play-calling, he’d say, “What you’re really asking me is why didn’t we win?” Chuck had many ways of getting his message across with succinct use of words. For example, when Chuck found himself having to repeatedly answer the question about when a player would be recovered from injury and able to play, Chuck might answer, “Nobody knows.” If you were the subject of a “nobody knows” answer, it was time for you to get healthy. My all-time favorite draft-day response in a press conference comes from Tom Coughlin, who can be very diplomatic in choosing his words when the occasion demands. Following the selection of a player who had been suspended by the university for his part in a dormitory fire, Coughlin said, “Now, we all know the unfortunate story about a dormitory room and an incendiary device.”
Jonathan from Saint Joseph, MO
Is this a do or die year for Coach McCarthy?
Why do fans love to fire the coach? As the Titans were in the process of rallying for one of the great wins in franchise history on Saturday, Pro Football Talk was posting a story proclaiming Mike Mularkey might be the next to go. Mularkey is the coach of a team that won three games just two years ago. He’s reversed the fortunes of the franchise, yet, as the Titans were rallying for one of their greatest victories, Mularkey was on the hot seat. It’s Nutsville, but it’s what the fans want so the media and the owners play to it. The wolves are in control. Just howl, baby.
Steve from Phoenix, AZ
I’m a Badgers fan. I watched the first round of the playoffs. I hate to say it but I don’t think Wisconsin could have effectively competed with the all-around speed and depth I saw on the field. I think things worked out very well for them this year.
Wisconsin played a horribly weak regular-season schedule, lost to a non-playoff team in the Big 10 title game, and then beat a Miami team that finished its season with three consecutive losses, two of them by wide margins. Still, the record looks great, and Wisconsin has an opportunity to use their 2017 fame to recruiting advantage. That’s what has to happen for Wisconsin to go to the next level; it must recruit better. It’s a good three-star program, but Ohio State and Penn State are recruiting at a higher level.
Les from Oshkosh, WI
It would appear your 1/1 response to Brandon about putting Edgar Bennett and everyone else on the hot seat wasn’t an overreaction. I am disappointed he was dismissed so quickly while the head coach was given a year extension covertly in October.
Edgar is a top coach and he will grow from this experience. His situation is nearly identical to Tony Dungy’s. Tony became Steelers defensive coordinator at a young age but faced a demotion following a terrible season in 1988. Rather than accept the demotion to defensive backs coach, he took the same position in Kansas City. His career quickly blossomed. I believe the same will happen to Edgar. Just as Tony had spent too much time in Pittsburgh, as a player and then as a coach, Edgar had spent too much time in Green Bay. You can get stale when you stay in one place too long. With this, Edgar will begin to move. There are 32 teams in this league.
Curt from Pennsylvania
Vic, I’m just curious. Take yourself back in time to just before the first Packers-Vikings game, when the Packers had only one loss and, of course, not knowing all the subsequent injuries to come, what were your expectations of the Packers’ season at that point.
My expectation was Aaron Rodgers would camouflage the roster’s deficiencies and take the Packers into the playoffs.
Chuck from Madison, WI
Vic, glad to find you again! What is your opinion of Damarius Randall, his play, his on-field demeanor, his recent comments about teammates not being held accountable?
The more he popped off, the better he played. I can live with that. Deeds, not words, right?
Chris from Lexington, KY
I’d like to hear your take on Clinton-Dix’s comments.
He didn’t have a great season. The words ring a little hollow.
Derek from LaCrosse, WI
What is your favorite Ted Thompson story?
I don’t have one. That’s kind of sad.
Mike from McFarland, WI
Would Hundley’s value in this league be higher right now if he hadn’t played this year? Is mystery and hype more appealing to a team than knowing?
Gary Cuozzo, huh? Chico Ruiz said, “Bench me or trade me.”
Jerry from Savannah, GA
Vic, why do teams have to grant permission before certain interviews are allowed? Seems a bit communistic.
College football should be so communistic. If it was, it wouldn’t bear the embarrassment of the coach of one team coaching another team.
Dan from Michigan
How much of the Patriots dynasty is due to a weakness of the AFC? It seems like every year they have a bye and their first playoff game is against a team that isn’t playoff caliber. If the Packers received two byes every year for the last eight years, I think we’d have more than one Super Bowl as well.
What would you say about the Packers’ road to the Super Bowl in 2010? Jay Cutler and the Bears in the NFC title game, and Todd Collins and somebody named Mr. Hanie played most of the game? Packers fans need to see the Packers through the same eyes they view the rest of the league.
Ben from El Paso, TX
What if Mariota loses possession before the ball breaks the plane and tumbles into the pylon, incomplete or fumble?
Al Riveron would’ve burst into flames. Seriously, that’s a great question. Mariota wasn’t going to the ground to make the catch, so my guess is he wouldn’t have had to survive the ground, which would’ve made losing the ball into the pylon a touchback. That’s my take on it, but you never know about Riveron. Also, if I’m Mike Mularkey, I use that play as an example to my players to not use the pylon when you can use the goal line.
Steve from Natrona Heights, PA
Who do you like next week in the Pittsburgh/Jacksonville game?
I like Natrona Heights, because it’s my hometown.